I do have a question for opinions.....how do we know if we have intuition or a refusal to believe the truth ?
From the first moment my gut told me that we were not over, but at what point do you keep faith in your gut when you keep wondering if it is just a refusal to see reality ?
Am I blinded by hope or delusional ?
When I read this, I have always had what we once referred to as an "inner knowing", the sensation that this was not over and I also questioned if I was believing in something in some sort of unhealthy psychological state...every time I assess this, I come up with the same conclusion. I am not delusional in any other area of my life, I don't have any other psychological issues, my therapist never felt that I was unhinged....
I do not know the answer to your question. What is the truth? That he is never coming back? Nobody knows that for sure.
What has helped me is looking at my present day reality. He doesn't want me in his life. He has a life of his own which he seems happy with. Contact with him does not mean that he wants "us" again..and thus, there are no expectations or questions about why he contacts or brings me gifts..it's just the way he is.
I think the question is, is this feeling stopping you from living your life?

If it is, then is it really a problem. If not, it may just be something in our brains that remain stuck on the idea of what once was.....it may not be possible to erase those feelings or the hope that we have.
What I am thinking here is that the present reality is that he is not my partner. I don't ask or expect anything from him. That's my reality.
Some of the posters here have written about reconnection which is not to be confused with reconciliation. And maybe that inner knowing is more a continuation of the bond between you that might always exist but doesn't mean he is coming back.
It's really totally out of our control. Any relationship going forward with him has to be initiated by him and it has to be real...not sending a joke in a text message.
I really would not worry unless these feelings are stopping you from exploring and living your life to it's fullest. Perhaps it was Heartblessing that used to say, the LBSer grows and builds their own life and if the MLCer ever comes through their tunnel, they would be the ones that have to catch up to the LBSer..which may of course be too late anyway for we too have been on our own journey.