Thank you, everyone, for your replies.
I say keep them but package them with a warning that they contain information that cannot be unknown and will likely be painful. But, those journals may save a future descendant from even further pain. Let me explain:
I found hundreds of pages of microfiched court testimony from my grandparents´divorce. Without that, I would not have understood the dysfunction that carried on down to the next generation. It explained many hurtful family behaviors- did not excuse, but explained. That knowledge, while painful, let me let go.
Yes, I definitely think the past can help those in the future. I wish there was more personal documentation in families. It has to be read with compassion & context, knowing this is likely not the full story, but I feel my story is worth preserving for those purposes.
...my current feeling is that I want to get rid of all the physical, written evidence of the very broken person I was eight years ago...
Oh, Mitz, but look at the journey & what you have become! Such a strong woman. You deal with your MLCer & the interactions between your children & their father more than most of us. We were all completely broken. It's what this does to a loving partner.
If I am honest with myself, I probably keep the journals so maybe one day if my H ever came back I would want him to read them and get some idea of how hurt I was.
They were painful pages to read. He could see how badly he hurt me.
But not that long ago I tossed them all, after reading them. I have no desire to have him or anyone else read them.
The woman who wrote those journals is not me anymore. I felt very sorry for her.
Yes, Thunder, that was one of my reasons as well. When I really did believe he would be coming back, I thought the journals could help in the counseling sessions we would have. As time goes on & I believe less & less in any sort of restored R, that is less of a reason to keep them. Even if that situation presented itself, so much time would have passed &, as you say, we have become different people.
I did read through what I had written, probably when the journaling was slowing down & I was strong enough not to be completely triggered by the memories. I was a very broken person for a long time after BD. So unlike my usual self it astounded me. But I am not ashamed of that. It humbled me, it made me more compassionate for what other broken people have suffered. That we never know what obstacles others are trying to overcome.
My journal files are arranged in kind of a weird way. My present plan is to (eventually) reorganize the files, read them, & print them out. I'll place them in a sealed package, with perhaps the "warning" label FTT suggests, placing them with my other "important papers". I kind of like the idea of a granddaughter or great-granddaughter, or great-great niece reading it as kind of a personal/historical document.
Hugs All,
HT
Detach and Survive: A Book of Self-Care for the Wives of Midlife Crisis Men
The Journey from Abandonment to Healing, Susan Anderson
Healing the Shame that Binds You, John Bradshaw
The Addictive Personality, Craig Nakken
https://www.midlifecrisismarriageadvocate.com/chapter-contents.htmlM'ed 41 years
BD-Jan 2013
Legally separated Feb 2013
D'ed without my consent July 2015
H M'ed OW Sept 2015