Definite replay for 2 years post BD. Then a year of I'm not sure what. There seemed to be progress. The usual replay behaviors had stopped. We were reconnecting - slowly. I thought I saw more progress. It didn't seem to be depression, maybe limbo. Then I think I saw depression, now definite withdrawal, but at the same time he has started up with some new replay behavior. So maybe he's back in replay, trying to avoid looking at himself. I'm not sure he'll go back to his crazy replay behavior, as his OW1 (EA) who he did all that stuff with is gone, but there's a whole world of new replay if he wants to continue to run away.
I'm not sure why he can't just figure out that "we" aren't the problem, but that means he has to look at himself for the answers and who wants to do that?