Baxter,
I didn't exactly counter-sue; where we are you have to have grounds for a divorce in the first 2 years, i.e. one has to accuse the other of 'unreasonable behavior'. What I did was write back (through L) to say that I didn't admit to those accusations, but that if he was so determined to divorce then I couldn't stand in his way (was very definitely advised not to contest, as here that means a trial, and basically just costs huge amounts of money without stopping the divorce) and if I had to be divorced then it would not be on lies, and that I would be the one to file.
That would have meant that I would have had to accuse him of things. I had told him that putting such accusations about me on public record was a cruel act, and that I would have given him many qualities, but never cruelty. That really hit him hard; he doesn't like to be thought of as bad.
It never got that far; somewhere during that time he broke down and said that he was a mess, was miserable, had no one to talk to, all that. I then wrote to him saying that he should know that I had a meeting to take the petition further, but that given what he had told me I would do what he wanted, i.e. go ahead, postpone, or cancel. He said to cancel, as he didn't know what he felt.
I now know that that was around the time he realized that the alienator who had precipitated him leaving was a total nutter, but it could also have been the thought of being accused that stopped it. H has always had a fear of being thought the bad guy or the villain in this, he has said so in those words.
He has never picked up the action, even though at this point accusations would no longer be necessary. When our daughter asked him back in the fall if he was going to divorce me, he told her that he would 'at some point'.
Who knows.