Yes, he is still in replay and you are right, it doesn't do any good to analyze it. It really is pointless to try to figure out time frames I have found. They do cycle so much and every MLCer is different. They get through it when they get through. My H started out before and after BD with the crazy, frantic behavior. Then it died down a lot but I have seen it wax and wane throughout with cycling. It isn't frantic anymore, but some of the replay behavior would get better and I would think he was done with it and then somehow it would creep back in again.