Yes, I agree, especially with vanishers because there are so few interactions each interaction makes a bigger difference, one way or another, than if you have a live-in MLCer.
I remember the Leaver's comments over the years, b/c there wasn't much to remember. If someone slapped you in the face one time, ten years ago, you would remember it well BUT if you are getting slapped over and over everyday, you just can't remember each and every one, even if they are all equally painful.
Four years ago, after he left, I needed to contact him for divorce information. When I realized that I didn't have the required information I needed b/c no one told me I said to him, "how was I supposed to know? You won't talk to me." He yelled at me, "why would I want to talk to you when all you do is use me as a punching bag!?!"
This was after four months of zero communication, I gave him all the space he asked for, he moved in with the girl and I was a complete puddle, but I did not contact him at all. I had no idea where he got the punching bag idea, I mean, geez, I said nothing.
All I could come up with is the days after BD, but there was no anger, just crying. It was in his head.
Did I slip in four years and show anger? Well, yeah. Again, I'm human. Overall, most people who know us, think I've been too kind. It's a fine line, only each of know what we can take, and how to handle the crap we have been given. We want our families back, but none of us want to be doormats, either.
That's why I was so surprised that he contacted me right after our scream-fest. In the early days, not only would he have not contacted me after, heck he would have hung up the first two minutes. Nope, he took it. It wasn't just me screaming and him taking it though, he had some anger too. Again, we both had things to get off of our chests. After we calmed down, we still talked about serious issues, and then by the end we were both joking and just talking like we did when we were married.
Now did I do anything different to "lure" him back? I don't think so. In fact, I was kinder to him in the early days. I think if I was a complete b!tch to him, yes, that would keep him away. Other than that, I'm just being myself, who happens to be pretty much the same person he loved for 25+ years, only a little more independent.