Hi RCR, I'm glad you weighed in here. I agree with you. Specific situations maybe do require NC.
My point was it shouldn't be recommended, as a blanket statement, to all newbies to do it right after BD when they are confused, not understanding MLC and have this horrible urgency to know why? What happened? My world was turned completely upside down. Even when people said time is my friend.
I could not comprehend that. Time? My friend? My H has just told me he wants a D.
I could not have understood what NC would have accomplished and I probably couldn't have done it.
Now having said that, if my H had told me he found someone else and wanted to be with her I probably would have gone NC right away without even being told. I would not have had any contact with him in that case, but that wasn't my case.
I see rare instances where NC is required, but not many. I just don't feel it is useful in the beginning, if you want to reconcile or Pave the Way, unless there is abuse of some kind, mentally or physically.
Bad Monster, yep NC. Physically hurting you, yep NC. But if they are just confused? Why not just go light and friendly and validate what they are saying?
It worked in my case. I stopped fighting him. Stopped trying to explain/defend myself. I listened and just went the "Sorry you feel that way" route.