I wanted to know, I needed to know. When they are in the same town, when it is possible that you could be standing right next to them in the grocery store, YOU NEED TO KNOW. It is not fair to not be told! Why should she be protected and from what.. you? You can put her into her place in the scheme of things when you know who she is. I too did not want secrets.
My belief was, if my h wanted a life with me, then it had to be based on honesty. TELL me everything I need to know. Knowing who the OP was, is an important fact. We all know he/she is just a bandaid but when we don't know who the bandaid was, it simply breeds more insecurity for us. Why will he not reveal her to me? What is this precious little secret that they are sharing?
I've only run into OW once since we reconciled... once in 6 whole years. She now works on the same floor as my h, I have eliminated going to his work place, as I have no desire to run into her again. I am not afraid of her, or even care about her, I just don't want to be near her, ever. I don't blame her, at least not as much as I blame my h. I don't give her a total pass, that is for sure, she is a scank unworthy of washing my floors.
You are either my spouse or you are not. You do not get to have the privilege of having a dirty little secret with some UNKNOWN person. Or tell or not tell! You lost the right to your privacy and the OP's too. He/she is not entitled to protection. Protect me... forget about OP! Spouses only concern, should be what will make LBS feel safe, secure, loved again! No more nasty surprises... just tell it all, get it out there. Equip your LBS with the tools he/she needs to heal him/herself.
hugs Stayed...