I understand everhopeful's question. I've been contemplating this for a good long time myself. Many write that their spouses are currently in crisis, and they are not themselves. How do you know that this is not the new 'them'?
In my case, not much really has changed... She is still doing all the things she used to do, just without me. There really is no hatred, or monster... just that she wants to live alone, and be a single mother. Because she doesn't love me anymore.
I've come to realize that she does have an Avoidant Personality Disorder. Something that I didn't even know about.
I've come to realize that those with this disorder may not be able to fully meet a spouse's needs emotionally. She could never talk to me heart to heart... I knew something was missing in her... I always wondered why I was able to talk to my sister and many other friends freely, but I couldn't do the same with her. I just couldn't pinpoint what it was.
In all the time that we've been together, I can count the number of disagreements (arguments) we've had in one hand. That is also abnormal.
I feel so sorry for her. Those with this disorder are so afraid of conflict, that they 'pretend to be happy' and let others have it their way. They are so afraid of someone not liking them, and ridiculing them that they prefer to have no friends.
My ex has no friends in the 23 years I've known her. I thought it to be a bit odd, but accepted it. She doesn't speak to her sister nor her mother.
Although many of the things she has done showed signs of MLC, there is no way for me to be 100% sure. I have almost no doubt that she has an Avoidant Personality Disorder though. There is a correlation between AvPD and MLC.
I've also never had a long term relationship with another woman, so I really didn't know how life could be. Now I realize your spouse can also be your friend, and meet your needs emotionally. My ex was always aloof, a bit cool emotionally, not very affectionate... except in the beginning of our relationship. She never talked to me at length about her wants and needs... never 'dreamed' with me. Everything we talked about was very task or moment driven. What to eat, what to do for the kids.... etc. She always seem to have a mild level of depression.... never really joked or laughed.
Even our kids say mommy never laughs...
If you are to stand, how do you know how long to stand for? Perhaps my ex being divorced, no longer needs to pretend that she is happy, and pretend to like the things I like... or pretend to be the happy stay at home mom.
Getting a job may be difficult for her.... and finding another man to marry.... not sure how easy that is too....
This just means continued lifetime alimony for me. I really love her, but I wonder why I never saw this evident personality disorder in her... perhaps I did, but dismissed it. I knew she was a little off, but didn't know it would affect so greatly.
I know that there are no guarantees in another relationship, and there are so many damaged souls out there (myself included) that finding someone else seems like a gamble. I have not given up on hope and love and marriage.
I still believe in it, but if Ex was to R with me, what's to prevent this from happening 10, 15 or 20 years from now? At that point, 'starting over' would be impossible, and I would be looking for a dependable companion to take care of me, and me of her. I've never had so much doubt about my future as I have now.
It's 20 months after BD, and we are complete with our D, and our marital home is finally sold. I've always cycled between wanting to stand, and wanting to move on- even since the beginning right after BD. This has not changed.
It is not likely that should would risk the humiliation to come and apologize to me or to see an R. That is at the crux of her avoidant characteristics. Even if she did it today, I'm not sure what I would say.
I love her as much as the next stander, but what is best for me and my future? Many Questions, very few answers.