There is clearly a schism on the forum. I only follow a few threads and check in when an occasional veteran posts, but even I can see it. I was going to refrain from commenting, but it does seem to be time to address the changes in a coherent way. In 2010, it was all about standing, being an obstacle to divorce and remaining "married" and true to your spouse, at all costs--even costs to yourself and your children. People left when they stopped standing. And there is no way I would agree there were more R’s in the early days. I have seen very few healthy R’s here, on my other forum, or IRL. (And didn’t someone tell me HB ultimately left her H?)
As the site matured, more and more standers stepped down, and businesses need to grow or die. RCR allowed it to accommodate non-standers. Now may be a time to consider a small compartmentalization, as a growth strategy. As one of the original pot stirrers, I always thought there should be a place (or some color indicator) for true standers who want to hear nothing about anything else, and other codes to let people know they are open to discussing divorce, or other ideas.
Fact--true standers and non-standers have very different views of the world and MLC. There are very few people who truly are standing in a perfectly healthy manner. For everyone else, standing calls for a whole heap of denial, or cognitive dissonance at the least. True standing means you have to blameshift all the horrible things your spouse has done onto the dis-ease of MLC, watch them treat the OP like gold, throw their kids under the bus, and all the other BS and keep shining that light. Taking back a half-baked MLCer who is not ready to accept blame for all the hurt and devastation they have caused is pretty much a requirement for R—that takes a certain kind of person, and SOME of those people ARE weak. They stand because they are too lazy, afraid, negative, insecure, or a whole host of other things, to look for anything else. I am NOT saying ALL, but they exist and some are here.
Once you stand down, you see everything in a new way. When the anger takes over and you face the true pain of betrayal and begin to heal--you can never go back. It's like losing your virginity. Once you have sex and realize you did not give up your entire being and self respect, get pregnant or die of an STD, you can’t go back to preach about the big evil that is lust. When you no longer have to look at your spouse as the golden ring, you can see that your MLCer was weak and did heinous things to you and your kids, friends, etc. And you can see that maybe you were not all that healthy and let it happen, and as you start to get healthy and see the same signs in the deniers all around you, you feel like it might be helpful to point it out. And let me just say that there are also weak, lazy, angry people with low self-esteem and other issues here, too, and for a time, I was probably all of those (except lazy, I have never been lazy), neither side wins in that regard.
But standers fear moving on more than non-standers fear standing. And non-standers forget that they are talking to people who do not want to face that they or their spouse might be coD, narcs, subclinical PD, depressed, etc. What others perceive as “bitter” is really just war-weary wisdom. Seeing another shattered woman refusing to stand up for herself is hard. Teaching is a gift and most people do not have it, and too many people with 2X4s instead of kid gloves are truly trying to be helpful, but this is hard for the newbies to take and threatening to the insecure standers who are afraid they will lose a new member of their team.
The bottom line is NO ONE knows what makes an R and there are a LOT of marriages on here where R is truly NOT the best option. I am one of them. I despise divorce and would never have chosen this path. I would have been a martyr for my H. The fact that he was weak and chose to have an affair as a way out of what was truly a crappy M was, ultimately, a favor to me. NC, lowC, paving the way, no one KNOWS what is best for anyone, but veterans do know that sandpaper on raw burns is generally not the best path.
To stand, or not to stand is an individual choice and each of us have to choose our own crooked, horrible path through the mess. None of us know what that path looks like for anyone else or what equipment they are taking on that journey. To repeatedly criticize or encourage a woman to stand for a man in a situation we REALLY DO NOT KNOW may be just as irresponsible as telling her to run as fast as she can. Mean people suck and should be silenced, but people who offer alternative views are all offering the same thing—care in a public forum. People have to know that any responder could be a PhD psychologist or a crack who thinks God talks to them (sorry but I never bought that stuff from HB.). I could be a card-carrying delusional BPD who believes she channels Elvira, and all my posts could be lies—there is really no way to know, but some people have told me I have helped them. So be it, broken clocks are right twice a day. And every M that is presented on here should be suspect. Perfect Ms do NOT succumb to MLCs, true statement--something had to be amiss, and not everyone tells you their whole truth--because NONE of us KNOW our WHOLE TRUTH.
Bottom line, it’s RCR’s forum, take it, or leave it, literally. If you want your own forum where they rules are different, start one, but dwelling on something you cannot control, whether it is this forum's rules or someone else's stand is indicative of "issues!" So everyone should stop cat-fighting and be nice. Love and light, ll
The best thing about banging your head against the wall for so long is that it feels so good when you finally stop...
BD 1/16/10
D Final 7/21/11
exH married OW the next week and moved across the country to be with her...
LL CHOSE to live happily ever after...