Forgive me but I think I'm a little confused by the above. It sounds like you're saying if you had settled for this girl and married her, you would have eventually had an MLC. Are you asking if what some of us think is MLC is actually our spouse finally ending a relationship with someone they didn't love but had settled for.
This question is perfect for the title of this thread.
Sometimes on this site, It just might not be MLC. Really doesn't matter if it's MLC or not, the person who is left is still heartbroken and must do the same things.... detach, take care of ourselves and GAL.
So I often talk about my sister and her MLC boyfriend. Is my sister in a MLC, I don't think so. She's just selfish, a typical alienator. She dated her now boyfriend in college, he left her and married someone else behind her back. They were apart for over 20 years. My sister married another man when she was about 40 and they had two kids. I don't think she ever really loved her husband. He was a great guy, did everything she asked, still was never enough. I often felt bad for him.
Then the other guy started calling, and boom, she was done with her husband. Not an MLC, just selfish.
So what did my ex-BIL do wrong? Not one thing. Just like everyone on here, he was heartbroken. He detached and later on met someone else that appreciated him.
The boyfriend, MLC?? Oh Hell, yeah. I see it in his eyes,... every. single. time. He can't look at me. It's always a quick glance and then away. He knows I know. Is he happy? Not even close. He is just stuck with his decisions. Will he ever go back to his wife? I really have no idea.
So, yes, my sister with her husband settled for a relationship with someone that she didn't love. She was 40, never got over her college sweetheart and wanted to have kids. She used a great guy and broke his heart for her own selfish agenda.
Her boyfriend, I think, decided maybe just maybe the grass would be greener if he chose the other woman so many years ago. I'm sure it was exciting when they were having an affair and my sister was always ready and waiting. Typical, isn't it? Now, however, the fantasy is over and he is stuck with a selfish person and life is no better, just the opposite. They have all the drama of trying to mix two broken families. My sister went from all smiles and giggles when he was first around back to her old self of "me, me, me". Guess he made his bed.
So looking back with our rose colored glasses off, we can decide if our spouses "settled" or if they really had some kind of break down. Either way, it still doesn't change the one thing that we can control,... our own actions. It's that simple.