The second step that Luskin describes is to recognize that this person that you have chosen to share your life with is imperfect; that imperfection means that they will say and do things to disappoint you, make you angry, or hurt you.
The first cause for this is the simple fact that everyone is different. The differences can be profound (different ethnic or cultural background, different religious upbringing) or simple (one partner preferring to pick up their dirty clothes while the other leaves them lying around, one partner loves Thai food while the other can't stand it). Those differences mean that they will see the world differently than you, react differently than you, and have different priorities than you. The second cause is that people make mistakes. They can be little mistakes (forgetting to run the dishwasher, losing your car keys) or large mistakes (forgetting to pay a bill, getting into an auto accident) but they will happen. This means that, even if you and your partner as the most compatible people ever, you will still find yourself becoming angry or upset by their actions. The third cause is that people inevitably act out of their own self-interest. Your partner decides to stay out late with friends and doesn't call to let you know; they buy a new laptop or take their parents out to dinner without telling you; they pass up a promotion that means better hours or more money because they like the position they have. (The obvious example in our cases would be the Replaying spouse who is carrying on an affair, consumed with drinking/drugs/gambling, or otherwise "getting to live their life".)
If you add your attitudes, your mistakes, and your self-interest to those of your partner it makes matters even worse. How does anyone manage to stay together? The answer is forgiveness -- both of your partner's shortcomings and your own. ("And forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive them that trespass against us.") This doesn't mean that you should keep quiet about the things that bother you, but forgiving them for what they did
before you have that talk will prevent emotion from clouding the discussion. If you are angry or upset, your body's fight-or-flight reflex is preparing you for conflict as it cannot tell the difference between stress caused by actual danger and stress caused by heightened emotions; if you and your partner are both agitated when you discuss a problem, the emotional reactivity can cause the argument to spiral beyond the original complaint.
Even though you are your partner come from different backgrounds, have differing opinions, and are capable of hurting the other accidentally or out of thoughtlessness, these differences and complaints do not have to cause a major problem in the relationship. Liking Thai food while your spouse does not doesn't have to cause a heated argument, so why does it? The answer lies in how you handle the differences and conflicts.
The biggest cause of anger or frustration that lasts long after the complaint or offense that causes it is attempting to enforce "unenforceable rules." Luskin describes this as a personal opinion or desire that is expressed as something that our partner "must" or "must not" do. When your partner breaks one of your unenforceable rules, it compounds the anger and resentment; it's not just that your partner lied to you, but that you have an expectation that they must not lie to you. The lie that your partner told is their responsibility; your expectation that they must not lie is yours.
Ask yourself who or what in your relationship must change for you to be happy, and you will discover your unenforceable rules. Ask yourself these questions:
1. Am I demanding that my partner treat me better than he/she does?
2. Am I demanding that my past with my partner be better than it was?
3. Am I demanding that my life with my partner be easier than it is?
4. Am I demanding that our relationship be fairer than I feel it is?
When you find yourself thinking in any of these ways, you have pinpointed an unenforceable rule.
The problem with unenforceable rules is that they are neither right nor reasonable; if they were, then people would adhere to them. An unenforceable rule is not the same as a wish or desire; hoping for a quiet night at home after a long day at work is not the same as getting angry because your spouse invited your in-laws over for dinner and didn't tell you.
(I'm going to step away from the book for a second and make it clear that I don't think that setting boundaries is the same thing as trying to enforce unenforceable rules. A boundary is not about what your partner does or does not do, but what you will or will not accept. Sometimes I see people trying to state their unenforceable rules as "boundaries", so I hope people read for themselves and try to grasp what Luskin is saying.)Fortunately, is it simple to recognize and work to eliminate unenforceable rules. The first step is to acknowledge that you are angry or upset; this helps you to identify your unenforceable rule at the time it is being broken. The second step is to recognize that your anger is due to the fact that the rule has been broken. The third step is to be willing to change your unenforceable rules and lessen the amount of anger or frustration you feel. (This is
not the same thing as forgiving or condoning that act that broke the rule.) The final step is to figure out how to hold onto the enforceable desire and get rid of the unenforceable demand. This can be simple as substituting the words "wish" or "hope" for "must" or "have to".
Unenforceable rule:* My partner must not lie to me.
Enforceable desire:* I hope that my partner does not lie to me.
By changing an unenforceable rule to an enforceable desire, you accept that your partner is imperfect and can or may disappoint you. But this should make it easier to deal with the specific complaint or problem without your emotions being clouded by the frustration of trying to enforce behavior that you have no control over.
Me: 45, Her: 40. Married 16 1/2 years, together(-ish) 20.
Status: BD 8/25/09, she moved out 8/28/10. No talk of D.
Every day is another chance to get it right.
http://www.vachss.com/mission/behavior.html"Counting days won't buy us years" —Wings by HAERTS
"Forgiveness means giving up all hope for a better past." —Lily Tomlin
"When we commit to our lovers, we implicitly promise to forgive them. There is no other way we can live with someone for better or worse or until death do us part." —Dr. Frederic Luskin