[Thunder]

I just read that, InIt.

That their relationship was volatile from the beginning.

[Roma]

Yes In it. The judge granted her a temporary restraining order. Apparently she has bruises. A volatile relationship. According to the article, this was not the first incident of violence.

http://www.coveragemail.com/entertainment/judge-grants-amber-heard-domestic-violence-against-johnny-depp-amid-divorce/

[kikki]

Except her description of how the bruises occurred (as written in the media - if the media is accurate) doesn't quite fit with the bruises shown in the photo.

[Anjae]

The LAPD says she had no signs of whatever harm Saturday. But we all know that a person in MLC can turn violent. In this case, I believe he could have done it, but I also believe she could had staged it. Situations like this are always extremely complicated. It is up to the police/any other experts to determine what really happened. 

[kikki]

Agree Anjae - either scenario is a possibility in these MLC situations

[Ready2Transform]

Another skeptic here. I too saw the reports on TMZ that the police saw no injuries when they were at the house after the argument, and she mentioned no violence then. She was tagged in Instagram pictures on Sunday with Amanda De Cadenet and Amber Valetta without any bruises at all, but the pictures were deleted on Monday. There's a reason she needed to marry for a career - BAD actress!

[Roma]

I don't know this lady yet realize bruises don't show for a couple of days. I wasn't there so I don't know for sure what's the truth.I want to think Johnny Depp wouldn't hurt her, yet we are all a product of MLC so who really knows?

[in it]

I thought the marks on the side of her face looked a lot like a cell phone. That's what she's saying he hit her with. Maybe that's what happened Saturday and she didn't have photos to take until Monday.

It took my arm three days to swell up and bruise after the incident I went through.

[Anjae]

She was tagged in Instagram pictures on Sunday with Amanda De Cadenet and Amber Valetta without any bruises at all, but the pictures were deleted on Monday

There is also that. And Depp's camp is pointing to those pictures are proof that she had suffered no harm. Of course she could have been wearing make up. If someone had screen caped the pictures, they may have been removed, but someone may have the screen caps.

The saying to the police that there has been no violence, does not proof much. It is normal for a woman in such situation to say so. And the police knows it, and so the lawyers (and judges).

Regarding the restrain order, if I was a judge, I may also want to play safe. When in doubt...

To me, the bruises do not look like been cause by an object I can identify. But I am not an expert, so, I have no idea if it was a phone or not.

I bruise easily. When Mr J grabbed by arms and shacked me, I was immediately left with bruises. Ugly one, from top to bottom. But I know it does not happen the same way to everyone.

This story is bringing back memories to me, and not nice ones.

[in it]

Me either Anjae